Doing good while reading good — join the Nonprofit Good News-Letter.
Challenge 20 in the series 50 Reasons Why It Is Hard to Run a Nonprofit
There's an assumption baked into nonprofit culture that goes something like this: you're doing meaningful work, so you should accept less money for it. It's rarely said that bluntly. But it shows up in every salary negotiation, every budget cycle, and every conversation where a nonprofit leader says, "We'd love to pay more, but we're a nonprofit."
I call this the mission discount — the unstated expectation that working for a good cause should come at a personal financial cost.
The compensation story in the nonprofit sector isn't as simple as "nonprofits pay less." It's more nuanced than that — and the nuance matters.
A Bureau of Labor Statistics analysis using National Compensation Survey data found that across the private sector, nonprofit workers actually earned more on average than for-profit workers in comparable industries. In education and health services — which account for the bulk of nonprofit employment — the nonprofit wage advantage was roughly $6.45 per hour, with total compensation (including benefits) running $11.28 per hour higher than for-profit equivalents.
So where does the "nonprofits pay less" narrative come from? Three places.
First, the sector comparison is misleading. When people compare "nonprofit pay" to "private sector pay," they're comparing a social worker's salary to a software engineer's salary. The relevant comparison is a nonprofit social worker to a government social worker to a for-profit healthcare company social worker — and on that basis, nonprofits often look competitive in wages but weaker in benefits and job stability.
Second, many "nonprofits" are in fact large institutions -- colleges, universities, hospitals. When you add in doctors and other highly-educated professionals into the mix (especially at salaries that are comparable to their for-profit peers), that skews the math, making "average nonprofit pay" a misnomer.
Third, the low end is genuinely low. Candid's 2024 Nonprofit Compensation Report found persistent gender pay gaps, regional disparities, and compensation floors that leave frontline workers unable to meet basic needs. In a separate study, 22% of nonprofit employees lived in households that couldn't afford basic necessities like housing and healthcare. That's not a pay gap — that's a poverty problem inside a sector that exists to reduce poverty.
And 55% of nonprofit organizations cite the inability to offer competitive salaries as a significant challenge. Whether or not the aggregate data shows parity, the lived experience of most nonprofit workers — especially those in smaller organizations, in rural areas, or in frontline roles — is that the money isn't enough.
The mission discount hurts more than workers. It hurts organizations and the people they serve.
It drives talent out of the sector. A 25-year-old with $80,000 in student debt can believe in your mission passionately and still not be able to afford to work for you. The sector loses talented people not because they don't care, but because caring doesn't pay the rent.
It creates a homogeneous workforce. When nonprofit jobs require a de facto subsidy from the worker's personal finances — a spouse with a higher income, family wealth, or willingness to live without savings — you get a workforce that skews toward people who can afford to be underpaid. That's a diversity problem disguised as a budget problem.
It increases turnover costs. The Johnson Center reports that nonprofit turnover runs at 19% versus 12% in other sectors. Every departure costs money — recruitment, onboarding, lost institutional knowledge, service disruption. Organizations that pay at the bottom of the market spend more on turnover than they save on salaries.
One of the arguments I make in Managing Your Nonprofit for Resilience is that underinvestment in staff — including compensation — is one of the primary ways nonprofits make themselves fragile. An organization that can't retain experienced staff can't deliver consistent services, can't build institutional knowledge, and can't sustain the relationships that make programs work.
Stop apologizing and start budgeting. If competitive compensation is a priority, it needs to show up in your budget, your grant applications, and your conversations with funders. "We're a nonprofit" is not a compensation strategy. "We budget for competitive salaries because retention drives outcomes" is.
Benchmark honestly. Use compensation data from Candid, your state nonprofit association, or the NonProfit Times salary surveys to see where you actually stand. Don't compare yourself to the private sector writ large — compare yourself to similar organizations in your geography and subsector.
Address the benefits gap. Even when nonprofit wages are competitive, benefits often aren't. Health insurance, retirement contributions, and paid leave are where the real gap shows up for many workers. If you can't match salary, can you strengthen benefits?
Name the mission discount and reject it. In your organizational culture, in board conversations, and in fundraising, make it clear that paying people fairly is part of the mission, not a trade-off against it. Donors who want your programs to succeed should want the people running those programs to be compensated well enough to stay.
Compensation strategy is one of those topics that's easy to talk about in generalities and hard to execute in specifics. The specifics are what I focus on in Nonprofit Good News Premium.
Look up your three most critical positions in a nonprofit salary database for your region. Compare those numbers to what you're actually paying. If there's a gap of more than 10%, that's a retention risk sitting on your books — and it belongs in your next budget conversation.
This is part of an ongoing series based on the 50 challenges outlined in Appendix 1 of Managing Your Nonprofit for Resilience (Wiley, 2023). Each post names one challenge clearly and offers a practical reframe with steps you can take this week. For deeper coverage of nonprofit strategy, risk, and resilience — including tools you can put to work immediately — check out Nonprofit Good News Premium.