Take the Risk Assessment Quiz
A mission‑first plan to diversify revenue, deepen donor loyalty, and build cash reserves—so you can lead, not scramble.
How can nonprofits escape the hamster wheel of constant fundraising and build more durable funding? Here are actionable strategies to regain control and align your financing with your mission – all while maintaining your organization’s resilience.
First and foremost, get crystal clear on your mission and strategic plan, and use that as a filter for fundraising opportunities. Not every dollar is worth chasing. As Donna Miller put it, a compelling strategic vision is your “guiding star” in turbulent times, preventing reactive decisions that lead to mission drift.
Sit down with your team and identify which funding sources truly align with your long-term goals. If a grant or donation comes with strings that pull you off course, think twice. By holding fast to a strategic plan (and updating it regularly as conditions change), you can concentrate on funding that furthers your mission, not distracts from it.
Our Lean Strategic Planning approach is designed for this purpose.It helps integrate strategy into daily operations so that you’re proactively steering the organization, rather than lurching from one funding crisis to the next. Leaders who implement Lean Strategic Planning establish clear goals and accountability, making it easier to say “no” to money that doesn’t fit and stay focused on what matters.
A resilient nonprofit has multiple streams of support, so it’s not perpetually soliciting from one source. Evaluate your current funding mix and identify gaps. Are you overly dependent on a handful of grants or a few major donors?
If so, prioritize diversification. This may involve creating individual donor programs, such as monthly giving to establish a consistent revenue stream, seeking corporate partnerships or sponsorships, investigating earned income through fees for services or social enterprises, and applying for grants that align with your overall strategy.
The key is balance. Relying heavily on just donations and grants while lacking other revenue can lead to inconsistent funding and cash flow crises. The solution is to build a diversified funding base, a mix of individual gifts, grants, corporate support, and earned revenue, all backed by solid financial planning and transparency with stakeholders.
For example, if you’ve historically funded programs mostly through an annual gala, start cultivating year-round individual donors at various levels. If you’ve never considered an earned income stream, brainstorm services or expertise your nonprofit has that could generate fees consistent with your mission. Diversification reduces the panic of worrying about where the next dollar is coming from and strengthens your ability to weather donor downturns.
Moving from perpetual fundraising mode to sustainable funding requires a shift in mindset from transactional to relational. Rather than viewing donors as one-time sources of cash, focus on building lasting partnerships with supporters. This means consistent, authentic communication about your impact, gratitude for every contribution, and engagement that makes donors feel like part of the mission.
By deepening donor relationships, you improve retention and increase the likelihood of multi-year gifts and bequests, which takes the pressure off yearly fundraising quotas. The data on donor retention may be sobering, but it’s also a call to action: nonprofits must double down on stewardship. Make sure to thank donors promptly and meaningfully, then report back on what their gift made possible. Consider creating a formal donor recognition or loyalty program.
When supporters see themselves as mission partners rather than ATM machines, fundraising becomes more fulfilling and predictable for everyone involved.
Nonprofit CEOs and development directors often feel perpetually stretched, but fundraising is a team effort. One practical step is to broaden the base of people involved in sustaining the organization.
Train your board members to be effective ambassadors and fundraisers (appropriate to their comfort level) rather than leaving all the fundraising to staff. Engage program staff in understanding the funding model too. They can often identify great stories and outcomes to share with donors, or even spot opportunities for support through their networks. Internally, break down silos between “program” and “development.” When everyone sees revenue generation as tied to mission fulfillment, a culture of shared responsibility can replace the feeling of a few exhausted individuals holding the bag.
Also, take a hard look at the workload and invest in capacity where needed. It may sound counterintuitive when money is tight, but dedicating resources to hiring a grant writer, a donor database manager, or even a fractional (part-time) fundraising professional can pay off by increasing efficiency and freeing leadership to focus on strategy. A supported, knowledgeable team can execute a smart fundraising plan far better than one or two overwhelmed individuals, and they’ll be more likely to stick around, thereby reducing costly turnover.
Finally, approach your nonprofit’s financial health the way any savvy business would by actively managing risks and building reserves. Constantly scrambling from one funding emergency to the next is a symptom of not planning for uncertainty. Through our Foundations for Growth framework (a lean risk management approach), we coach nonprofits to identify their most critical risks, and for almost every organization, funding volatility is near the top of that list.
By acknowledging this risk, you can take steps to mitigate it. Develop a contingency plan for funding shortfalls (e.g., what expenses would you trim or what funding could you tap in a pinch?). Set policies to build an operating reserve or cash cushion during better times. Even a few months of reserve can turn a funding crisis into a manageable problem. Use scenario planning to imagine best, moderate, and worst-case funding scenarios, and outline responses for each. When you proactively map out these strategies, you transform from being reactive to being resilient.
The “hands perpetually outstretched” challenge remains a defining issue for nonprofits, but it does not have to be a permanent state of being. By understanding how the landscape has shifted, and by taking deliberate steps like those above, nonprofit leaders can regain their strategic footing. The overarching theme is to move from reactive to proactive: instead of letting short-term fundraising pressures dictate your strategy, let your strategy dictate how you approach fundraising.
Yes, it requires discipline to occasionally say no to dollars that don’t fit, creativity to cultivate new funding sources, and persistence to build a culture that values planning and risk management. But the payoff is immense. Your organization can emerge more resilient, with funding streams that support rather than distort your mission. You’ll spend less time with your hand out and more time with your hand on the wheel, steering toward the outcomes you exist to achieve.
Risk Alternatives enhances the resilience and sustainability of nonprofits through comprehensive tools, training, and support. For inquiries about conducting a risk inventory or other matters, please contact Risk Alternatives at info@tedbilich.com.